The infamous "reprise clue"

[brackwater]

Hi, im new. And I believe the 60if rumor and all, but you got it wrong about Sgt Pepper reprise.

Heres what www.beatles-discography.com has to say about it.


In the very beginning, John says something like "Look up. Byeeee"

After Pauls "Whoo!" you hear John say "Paul can you hold my guitar for me?" Which you mistook as "Paul is dead, paul is dead" or whatever.

Then the talking at the end, it says "Also, Paul goes really mad with the singing. On mono versions, this is heard better. "We'll be back" or "We're the band, the greatest band of all time" and a faint "Sergeant Peppers Band!" finishing on the final chord"

[byrdsmaniac]

Well, OK, but they're not going to agree that what was said is, "Paul is dead; yeah, he's [glow=red,2,300]Really Really Dead[/glow] " or anything of the sort, so I think there's still room for speculation. (I buried sauce! ;D )

[ReallyReallyDead]

no matter how many times I listen, I can't hear "Paul can you hold my guitar for me", "well be back", or "were the band, the greatest band of all time"

I only hear
HEARTS (gibberish)
CLUB really really dead!
BAND Paul is dead, yeah, for the band anyway! (Whoooooo!) Thank you guauls and gentleman, yeah! (ringo: Seargent pepper's BAND)

[TPIMaster]

To me, it's

I don't want to scare anybody
Really really dead
How was that good for the band in a way?
Wooo! (Moth'f**ker heard in background) Thank you ladies and gentlemen!

Please read all topics before posting ;D and check out the 5.1 extraction. If I feel like it I'll try to change it in a vocals-only file.